BMW M240i vs M2: which compact BMW should you buy?
The M240i and M2 are both compact BMW coupés with straight-six engines. Engines, performance, drive, gearboxes, comfort, running costs and which one suits you best.
1 view 1 reading now 0 comments 4 min read
On this page
M240i vs M2 is a key question for anyone who wants a compact, fast BMW coupé. Both cars share the same basic body shape and a 3.0-litre straight-six, but they are aimed at different drivers.
The M240i is an M Performance model that combines strong performance with comfort and, in many markets, all-wheel drive. The M2 is a full M car with a wider body, a more powerful engine and a manual gearbox option. In this comparison we look at the current generations, the G42 M240i and the G87 M2, to help you choose.
Two compact coupés, two characters
The 2 Series coupé is one of the last compact rear-wheel drive based coupés on the market. BMW offers it in several versions, with the M240i at the top of the regular range and the M2 as the full M model.
The M240i is designed as a fast all-rounder: quick, comfortable and easy to use every day. The M2 is designed for maximum driving pleasure and track ability, with a more aggressive character. Our article on BMW M vs M Performance vs M Sport explains these categories.
M240i vs M2: engines
The engines are the core of the M240i vs M2 comparison:
- M240i: the B58 3.0-litre straight-six with a single twin-scroll turbo, producing around 374 hp in many markets. It delivers strong torque from low revs and smooth power delivery.
- M2: the S58 3.0-litre twin-turbo straight-six from the M3 and M4, producing 460 hp at launch and more after a later update. It revs higher and is built for track use.
The M2 feels much more intense when you push it, with a sharper throttle response and a more dramatic sound. Our article on the BMW S58 engine explains the M2 engine.
Drive and gearboxes
In many markets, the M240i is sold with xDrive all-wheel drive, which provides excellent traction in all weather. Rear-wheel drive versions exist in some markets. It uses an eight-speed automatic gearbox.
The M2 is rear-wheel drive only and is available with a six-speed manual or an eight-speed M Steptronic automatic. The manual option is a major reason why many enthusiasts choose the M2. An Active M Differential helps traction and agility. Our article on the Active M Differential explains how it works.
Chassis and handling
The M2 has a wider track, a stiffer body structure, M-specific suspension parts and larger brakes. Its steering is sharper and the car feels more planted on a circuit. It is one of the most enjoyable track cars BMW makes.
The M240i is still agile and fun, but its suspension is tuned for a wider range of conditions. It is more comfortable on bumpy roads and easier to drive fast in poor weather, thanks to xDrive.
Comfort and everyday use
For daily driving, the M240i has clear advantages. It is quieter, softer and less tiring on long journeys. Its lower running costs and all-weather traction make it a sensible daily car.
The M2 is firmer and louder. With adaptive dampers in their comfortable setting, it is usable every day, but it never feels like a relaxed cruiser. Many owners accept this because the M2 makes even short trips feel special.
Running costs and buying
The M240i is cheaper to buy and run. Fuel consumption, tyres, brakes and insurance are usually lower. The M2 uses wider tyres, bigger brakes and an M engine with specific maintenance needs.
On the used market, both cars hold their value well. Manual M2s are especially sought after. Our guide to BMW M car running costs explains what to expect when owning a full M car.
The previous generation
If your budget is lower, consider the previous generation. The F22 M240i and the F87 M2 offer similar strengths in a slightly smaller, lighter package. The original M2 used an N55 engine, while the M2 Competition and M2 CS used the S55 from the M3 and M4.
Our comparison of the M2 F87 and G87 explains the differences between the two M2 generations.
Which one should you choose?
Choose the M240i if:
- you want a fast, comfortable daily car;
- you value all-weather traction with xDrive;
- you want lower running costs.
Choose the M2 if:
- you want a full M car with maximum driving involvement;
- you want a manual gearbox;
- you plan to drive on track or on challenging roads often.
Both are excellent cars. The best way to decide is to drive both on the same day and on the same roads.
M240i vs M2 at a glance
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Category | M240i: M Performance | M2: full M car |
| Engine | M240i: B58 3.0 | M2: S58 3.0 twin-turbo |
| Power | M240i: around 374 hp | M2: 460 hp and more later |
| Drive | M240i: xDrive in many markets | M2: rear-wheel drive |
| Gearbox | M240i: 8-speed auto | M2: manual or 8-speed auto |
| Character | M240i: fast all-rounder | M2: focused M car |
| Running costs | M240i lower |
Frequently asked questions
Is the M240i faster than the M2?
In some acceleration tests from standstill on slippery roads, xDrive helps the M240i, but the M2 is faster overall, especially on a circuit.
Does the M2 have a manual gearbox?
Yes. The G87 M2 is available with a six-speed manual or an eight-speed automatic.
Is the M240i a good daily car?
Yes. It combines strong performance with comfort and, with xDrive, good traction in all weather.
Which is better on track, the M240i or the M2?
The M2, thanks to its M engine, wider track, stronger brakes and stiffer chassis.
Comments 0
Join the conversation — be kind, no links.
Loading comments…